Khoo Kay Aun and 6 Others v Koe Liew Hin and Another
Civil Appeal No. P-02(NCVC)(W)-22-01/2016; Court of Appeal
Date of Judgment: 01 December 2016 | Source: Federal Court Registry
The present appeal has been brought by the appellants in light of the High Court's decision in dismissing their claim and allowing the respondents' counterclaim on 30.11.2015. In the proceedings before the High Court, the appellants were the plaintiffs while the respondents were the defendants. The second to seventh appellants are suing as the trustees of Swee Thong Tong Khoo Kongsi whereas the respondents are sued in their capacity as the executors of the late Koe Choon Keng's estate. On appeal before this Court, we allowed the appeal in part as we were not in agreement with the learned judge in allowing the respondents' counterclaim. In the event, the order of the learned judge in respect of the counterclaim was set aside. The decision of the learned judge in dismissing the appellants' claim was however, affirmed.

DALAM MAHKAMAH RAYUAN MALAYSIA

(BIDANG KUASA RAYUAN)

RAYUAN SIVIL NO. P-02(NCVC)(W)-22-01/2016

ANTARA

1. KHOO KAY AUN (No. K/P: 401107-07-5369) (selaku Pegawai Awam dan mendakwa bagi Swee Thong Tong Khoo Kongsi)

2. KHOO HENG CHUAN (No. K/P: 290127-07-5389)

3. KHOO HOCK SOON (No. K/P: 490419-07-5285)

4. KHOO KAY HOCK (No. K/P: 550315-07-5143)

5. KHOO KHAY HOCK (No. K/P: 420726-07-5265)

6. KHOO SOO KEAN (No. K/P: 640501-07-5429)

7. KHOO BOO KEONG (No. K/P: 680515-07-5231) (Plaintif Ke-2 hingga Plaintif Ke-6 mendakwa sebagai Pemegang Amanah bagi Swee Thong Tong Khoo Kongsi) ... PERAYU-PERAYU

DAN

1. KOE LIEW HIN (No. K/P: 520907-07-5297) (sebagai wasi bagi wasiat Koe Choon Keng, si-mati)

2. KOE CHUNG BENG (No. K/P: 550814-07-5447) (sebagai wasi bagi wasiat Koe Choon Keng, si-mati) ... RESPONDEN-RESPONDEN

[DALAM MAHKAMAH TINGGI MALAYA DI PULAU PINANG

GUAMAN SIVIL NO. 22NCVC-306-10/2013

1. KHOO KAY AUN (No. K/P: 401107-07-5369) (selaku Pegawai Awam dan mendakwa bagi Swee Thong Tong Khoo Kongsi)

2. KHOO HENG CHUAN (No. K/P: 290127-07-5389)

3. KHOO HOCK SOON (No. K/P: 490419-07-5285)

4. KHOO KAY HOCK (No. K/P: 550315-07-5143)

5. KHOO KHAY HOCK (No. K/P: 420726-07-5265)

6. KHOO SOO KEAN (No. K/P: 640501-07-5429)

7. KHOO BOO KEONG (No. K/P: 680515-07-5231) (Plaintif Ke-2 hingga Plaintif Ke-6 mendakwa sebagai Pemegang Amanah bagi Swee Thong Tong Khoo Kongsi) ... Plaintif-Plaintif

Dan

1. KOE LIEW HIN (No. K/P: 520907-07-5297) (sebagai wasi bagi wasiat Koe Choon Keng, si-mati)

2. KOE CHUNG BENG (No. K/P: 550814-07-5447) (sebagai wasi bagi wasiat Koe Choon Keng, si-mati) ... Defendan-Defendan]

CORAM: ROHANA BINTI YUSUF, JCA; IDRUS BIN HARUN, JCA; MARY LIM THIAM SUAN, JCA

Please click here for the full text of the item.

For The Appellants - Mr. John Khoo Ismail, Khoo & Associates, Paras 4, Unit 9-11, Premier Centre, No. 253-G, Jalan Burmah, 10350 Pulau Pinang.

For The Respondents - Mr. Simon Murali, Lio & Partners, 29, Green Hall, No. 29, Lebuh Pantai, 10400 Pulau Pinang.

Notice: The Publishers of MLTIC acknowledge the permission granted by the relevant official/original source for the reproduction of the above/attached materials. You shall not reproduce the above/attached materials in whole or in part without the prior written consent of the Publishers and/or the original/official source. Neither the Publishers nor the official/original source will be liable for any loss, injury, claim, liability, or damage caused directly, indirectly or incidentally to errors in or omissions from the above/attached materials. The Publishers and the official/original source also disclaim and exclude all liabilities in respect of anything done or omitted to be done in reliance upon the whole or any part of the above/attached materials. The access to, and the use of, MLTIC and contents herein are subject to the Terms of Use.